Send Comments to the Editors

U.S. Mail:
The Rice Thresher
6100 Main Street (MS-524)
Houston, TX 77005-1892

Telephone:
Voice:
(713) 527-4801
Fax:
(713) 285-5238

Internet: thresher@rice.edu

I.D. cards fall short of miraculous potential
by Brian Stoler
RICE UNIVERSITY identification cards -- those easy-to-misplace, off-white pieces of plastic with your name, college and year of graduation. Some cards, like mine, also come with an unrecognizable or unflattering mug shot of the owner. (Like the Thresher head shots?)

However, IDs are useful for more than just humor at the holder's expense. They open up worlds of culinary possibilities thanks to Central Kitchen. Your ID provides access to Fondren library for a quiet escape from roommates. At least that's how my roomates use their cards.

You can use an ID to check out badminton equipment from Autry Court to let off some steam. And, freshmen, did you know that you can pay for the higher quality food and drink from Sammy's and the CoffeeHouse by simply presenting your card? When I first went to the CoffeeHouse, I was amazed that my card was sufficient payment.

Although they have some good qualities, there are some instances in which the need to use a Rice ID becomes a serious hassle

The card readers that protect communal bathrooms in some colleges are a particular pet peeve of mine. At first, I could not comprehend any rationale for their presence; now I think I understand the (flawed) argument.

Let me explain the logic behind bathroom card readers, as I understand it. Although card readers restrict access to the entire residence portion of the colleges, it is very easy for any person to get someone to let them in. Therefore, some "bad" non-Rice person could get into any of the colleges with relative ease. Bathrooms are a good way for criminals to catch potential victims unaware and alone, so they might want to hide in one.

Even though someone would likely open a bathroom door for a "bad" guy (or gal), if a crime did then transpire in that bathroom at around that time, the door-opener would have a good chance of remembering the characteristics of the person they let in.

Is the possibility of a slightly higher chance of getting caught going to deter a potential criminal? Is it really more likely for a crime to occur in a bathroom than in say, a stairwell? And if bathrooms are such a security hazard, why don't we have some kind of protection on bathrooms in public buildings such as the Student Center?

What's really funny about this situation is that access to the bathrooms is not even limited by gender -- I can just walk up to a women's restroom, insert my card, and walk in! What kind of security is that?!

Removing the card readers from the bathrooms would have little effect on safety and would make them more user-friendly. Can you imagine how many carpet cleanings could be avoided if drunken students were able to get into the bathrooms before they threw up?

Gripes about bathrooms aside, there many possibilities for the expansion of the use of IDs. Standard room door locks could be replaced with card readers, like in some hotels. This would give us one less thing to lose, and if someone were to lose his or her ID card, all the ID card department would have to do is invalidate the previous card and authorize a new one, as opposed to having to re-core a lock and grind new keys, an expensive and time-consuming process. Similarly, access to college commons' should be restricted by card, not by key.

More services should accept ID cards as payment. If the mixing of meal plan charges with other charges offends Food and Housing, why not make another balance that works off of the same card? This balance would, in my idealistic world, be consumable at the Campus Store, at vending machines and even for pizza delivery.

Sounds far-fetched? Other universities across the nation have already implemented card plans such as these. If these services could be paid for with the invisible money of IDs, their use would likely go up. (Paying with plastic, the purchase seems free!) These cards would also allow cash withdrawals from a balance, giving students an easy way to get quick cash on campus.

So maybe you think that this column is nothing more than an idealistic rant from a whining freshman. But the next time you are standing outside the bathroom with your legs crossed watching the little red light deny you, or when you are a nickel short of liquid refreshment, this column's significance will become apparent.


This item appeared in the Opinion section of the October 10, 1997 issue.

Copyright © 97 The Rice Thresher. All Rights Reserved.
This document may be distributed electronically, provided that it is distributed in its entirety and includes this notice. However, it cannot be reprinted without the express written permission of:
The Rice Thresher, Rice University, 6100 Main, Houston, TX 77005-1892, USA.


The Thresher Online Project -- ethresh@listserv.rice.edu