Chicago Tribune, Sunday, November 10, 1991
By Casey Bukro
A bitter clash between federal and Michigan environmental officials over
building an 18-hole golf course on a luxury resort in scenic northwestern
Michigan is shaping up as a conflict that could set national standards for
wetlands preservation.
Environmentalists said they are watching the case as a barometer of the
Bush administration's commitment to wetlands protection, while Michigan
authorities said the case is a model of strict guidelines for permitting
wetlands development.
Valdas Adamkus, the Environmental Protection Agency's Midwest regional
administrator, already has ruled that the site chosen by The Homestead for
the golf course is environmentally wrong because turf chemicals might
contaminate the pristine Crystal River and nearby Sleeping Bear Dunes
National Lakeshore.
The project proposed to fill in pockets totaling 3.68 acres of cedar swamp
wetlands, which Adamkus also resisted because wetlands destruction is a
highly sensitive environment issue.
In an unprecedented move, Adamkus on Nov. 21, 1990, revoked a wetlands
development permit offered to the condominium resort by the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources and turned the case over to the U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers.
It was viewed as a slap in the face by Michigan, the only state to which
the EPA has delegated authority to issue wetlands development permits. The
state has issued 20,000 of them.
The EPA declared the golf course project "dead."
Passions smoldered until Michigan's new governor, John Engler, raised the
issue with EPA Admimstrator William Reilly. On Sept. 17, Reilly ordered
the case reopened.
Officials from the EPA and Michigan are to meet next week.
John Truscott, the governor's spokesman, said the EPA "is intruding on the
authority they have given us,... We should be allowed to issue the
permits, or we'll turn it back to EPA.
"What The Homestead has done is set the standard for the whole country
as far as wetland permits," Truscott continued. "That's the one silver
lining in this whole process. The permitting process and the protection
process has jumped light-years ahead of where it was just a couple of
years ago."
Environmentalists call it the most bitter wetlands preservation battle in
the nation.
"This is the test case over whether EPA is willing to stand behind
wetlands protection in this country," said Brett Hulsey, director of the
Sierra Club's Great Lakes program. "Everything we've seen indicates the
Bush administration is retreating on its promise to protect wetlands.
Wetlands are nature's sponges, soaking up flood waters and high lake
levels--even filtering out pollution in waterways. They are nurseries for
fish and waterfowl.
Under pressure from farmers, developers and the oil industry, the Bush
administration is redefining wetlands so that as much as a third of the
100 million acres of bogs, swamps and marshes in the Lower 48 states would
be vulnerable to development.
Scott Jones, president of Friends of Crystal River, a grass-roots group
opposed to the golf course, called Engler's action "a blatant abuse of
political pressure and highly inappropriate for the governor to intervene
on behalf of a private developer."
The Homestead, a $ 120 million, 500-acre resort in Glen Arbor, about 25
miles northwest of Traverse City, is Michigan's largest resort.
Owner-operator Robert A. Kuras said he needs a golf course to retain a
competitive edge in the state's rapidly growing resort industry.
In 1986 Kuras proposed building a $3.5 million golf course on 26 acres
adjoining the resort, including 83 acres of wetlands--of which 3.68 acres
would be filled.
The wetlands area is heavily wooded with cedar trees and dry except during
heavy rains. It is ridged by shallow swales, and cut by the meandering
Crystal River, which flows through The Homestead and adjacent Sleeping
Bear Dunes National Lakeshore before emptying into Lake Michigan.
In a 1987 referendum, Glen Arbor Township residents voted 285-209 to
rezone the land for the golf course. In 1988 and again in 1989 Michigan's
Natural Resources Department denied the permit, citing the river.
From the beginning , Friends of the Crystal River fought the plan.
"We're not agatnst a golf course for the resort," said Jones, a Hinsdale
resident who has a summer home near The Homestead. "We just don't want it
in the wetlands." He has alternative sites 4 or 5 miles away.
Kuras said the golf course must be close to the resort to be practical and
economical, and he sued the department. An administrative law judge ruled
in support of the permit on Aug. 27, 1990.
Nine days later the EPA warned that filling any wetlands would be a
violation of the federal Clean Waters Act.
On Nov. 14, 1990, the Michigan agency offered The Homestead a permit with
20 conditions that included managing and monitoring pesticide and
fertilizer chemical runoff from the golf course.
Kuras objected. "I have yet to find anything remotely close to the
standards we've been held to," he said.
Adamkus says the case breaks down into two issues, preserving wetlands and
a pristine river.
"To keep the greens in top shape, it will take a lot of chemicals that
will run off into the stream and leach into the ground," says Adamkus. "We
don't see how we can sacrifice one of the clear, pristine streams
remaining in the country."
Fish and Wildlife Department, the Army Engineers and the National Park
Service also object to the golf course in that location, said Adamkus.
The proximity of the 71 ,000-acre Sleeping Bear Dunes National lakeshore
is a major concern since it was set aside by Congress in 1970 for
preservation in its natural condition.
The greater issue is wetlands.
"We've lost half of the wetlands in the country," notes Adamkus. "From
what I see, the remaining wetlands are in danger.
Source: Chicago Tribune, November 10, 1991